5 Secrets to Accurately Counting a Roundabout

Key Learnings from Counting a Six-Legged Roundabout

Guest Post by Max Moreland, PE, Director of Operations at Traffic Data Inc.

At Traffic Data Inc. we recently completed intersection turning movement counts in Cottage Grove, Minnesota including a couple of roundabouts. We’ve counted many roundabouts before however, one of those roundabouts is a large, multi-lane, six-leg roundabout which created some unique counting challenges.

With each vehicle having six potential movements plus multiple approach and circulating lanes, plus bicycles and pedestrians movements, there’s a lot to keep track of. In addition, there are trees and an artistic spiraled retaining wall that made it made it difficult to see to the other side of the roundabout (A side note – Bryant Ficek at our office helped with the planning and design of this roundabout. The spiral wall not only looks great, it does exactly what it’s supposed to do which is to keep traffic moving in the right direction).

How do you accurately count an intersection of this size? It turns out all you need is a COUNTcam, good birds eye view of the intersection, and a lot of patience.

As is standard at Traffic Data Inc., we use COUNTcams at each of the study intersections to record video in the field, then we complete the turning movement counts in the office using COUNTpro. Two of the six legs on the six-leg roundabout are entrance and exit ramps for an interchange, with the roundabout’s main road passing under the nearby highway. As we were looking for a place to setup the COUNTcam video cameras, we noticed a sign along the highway near the overpass and found it was a great spot to get a good top-down view of the six-leg roundabout. Being able to capture all six legs clearly in one camera was a lucky find and would prove invaluable as we counted the roundabout.

Banner-5-Secrets-to-Counting-a-RoundaboutRoundabout turning movement counts are never easy and this one proved to be trickier than most. However, that view of the six-leg roundabout made our counts in the office slightly less painful. To complete the roundabout counts, the person doing the counting had to focus on entering traffic from one leg at a time to accurately follow vehicles through the intersection to their exiting leg. Once the count was completed for one approach, it was repeated for the others. Fortunately, two of the six legs have one-way traffic, which reduced the counting load.

To ensure accuracy in our counting, we narrowed the time frame of the counting to just the a.m. and p.m. periods to make it more manageable and reduced the viewing speeds to 2x or 3x speeds to improve accuracy. During the roundabout’s heaviest use, we viewed the video at real-time speed. The benefit of the video for us was being able to collect the data and watch (and rewatch) the traffic flow as many times as we felt necessary to get an accurate count. This just wouldn’t be possible with personnel in the field.

While doing this count proved to be quite tedious, with the COUNTcam, and a bit of luck getting an elevated view of the roundabout from the camera we were able to get accurate counts. Are you counting a roundabout? Here are our secrets for accurately counting a roundabout.

  1. Record video from the highest view you can. We used a sign on an overpass in this case. The closer you get to a ‘bird’s eye’ or aerial view, the easier it will be to track vehicles.
  2. Count one leg or approach at a time. It gets too confusing to track multiple vehicles in and out of multiple legs (even four-legged roundabouts can be tough).
  3. View the traffic at a low counting speed. COUNTpro may allow up to 20x speed when counting, but you will not be able to accurately track all vehicles at that rate. Depending upon the actual volume, 2x to 3x speed is more realistic while at peak times real time speed may be necessary.
  4. Focus just on the time frame you need. We counted the a.m. and p.m. peak periods for this study, narrowing down the roundabout count to an hour and a half in the morning and an hour and a half in the evening. If you don’t need the additional data, don’t waste time trying to get it.
  5. Count total ins and outs on each leg for quality assurance. Match the total ins and outs against your turning movement counts.

One final, shameless plug. If you need to complete further roundabout capacity analysis after collecting the traffic data, take a closer look at our Roundabout Capacity Analysis spreadsheet.  This easy-to-use spreadsheet faithfully implements the processes of the Highway Capacity Manual on Roundabout. Now you too can complete capacity analysis in as little as 5 minutes.

Use the MS Excel based spreadsheet to help you assess the operational performance of an existing or planned one-lane or two-lane roundabout given traffic demand levels. This customizable spreadsheet allows you to adjust standard defaults, such as the lane utilization, critical headway or follow-up headway, according to local factors.

Please note: I reserve the right to delete comments that are offensive or off-topic.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

4 thoughts on “5 Secrets to Accurately Counting a Roundabout

  1. Hi, wondering how many hours of data you collected altogether (AM + PM = 2 hrs or 4?). And how many person-hours were spent counting in the office for this assignment?

    Thanks!

    • Mark – We had done a 6 am to 7 pm count at the adjacent intersections, so we were able to hone in on THE peak hours and only counted 60 minutes in the a.m. peak and 60 minutes in the p.m. peak. We watched the videos and counted one leg at a time at 3x speed. One leg of the roundabout was an on ramp, so we only had to count 5 legs. So…. each 60 minute peak hour count took a little less than two hours of office time to process. Mike

  2. I totally agree. Roundabout are the most difficult to count. They proved a nightmare using manual counts (as in persons counting on each arm), so having a camera definitely improves the situation. I think the critical point is having the camera at a high point. Without that you might not even be able to see all arms!
    Maybe a screenshot from the COUNTcam would have been a good addition to this article.